I think the question itself is not entirely true.

All  the traditional religions originated before pre-space epoch and in  respect of any natural disaster, the more space, involves the reliance  of people on some higher power. Moreover, these disasters are usually  perceived as a manifestation of the will (or anger) of these forces.

In  Asgardia in its conception the people themselves prevent disaster, i.e.  do not rely on a higher power, and to some extent take over their  function, and if they believe in something all together, it is only in  progress and human potential (as it was at the birth of practical  cosmonautics in the USSR in the late 1950s – early 1960s).

But in private, everyone can believe in anything, even in Santa Claus.

I think the question itself is not entirely true.

All  the traditional religions originated before pre-space epoch and in  respect of any natural disaster, the more space, involves the reliance  of people on some higher power. Moreover, these disasters are usually  perceived as a manifestation of the will (or anger) of these forces.

In  Asgardia in its conception the people themselves prevent disaster, i.e.  do not rely on a higher power, and to some extent take over their  function, and if they believe in something all together, it is only in  progress and human potential (as it was at the birth of practical  cosmonautics in the USSR in the late 1950s – early 1960s).

But in private, everyone can believe in anything, even in Santa Claus.

I think the question itself is not entirely true.

All  the traditional religions originated before pre-space epoch and in  respect of any natural disaster, the more space, involves the reliance  of people on some higher power. Moreover, these disasters are usually  perceived as a manifestation of the will (or anger) of these forces.

In  Asgardia in its conception the people themselves prevent disaster, i.e.  do not rely on a higher power, and to some extent take over their  function, and if they believe in something all together, it is only in  progress and human potential (as it was at the birth of practical  cosmonautics in the USSR in the late 1950s – early 1960s).

But in private, everyone can believe in anything, even in Santa Claus.

This kind of religion allready exists. They are named : Bahai'e and are installed in Turkey.

They believe in all Prophets from all religions - But this is not the solution. Every on has his own experience of belief and worship. Lets all Asgardian decide to practice their own religion and accept the religion of everyone

I think in Asgardia religion should be out. Religion is one of the main reasons of the current situation in Earth, so....why should we bring the same to this new future nation?. Those who need a religion should stay here then. Thats my opinion with all my respest to everyone.

Religion is a beautiful thing in books. Unfortunately as seen on earth, conflicts still occur.
Personally i'd like Asgardia to become a Non Religious Nation. But i'm not sure if that can be achieved. Because of that i think Asgardia should treat it's citizens the same, no matter what kind of Religion you believe. I think we have to implement that clearly into our laws. Better said. There should be no references to religion in our future book of laws to prevent friction or worse even War since that is one of our main goals of our Asgardian Nation.

knowledge , understanding and love

could be our peace and freedom.

Behavior as ''praying'' read diffrent books'' wear diffrent clothes'' - we dont have to do that. Everyone make their own choice. As far people are not forced to or brainwashed from childhood. Let children be free from belief  and let them choose who they wanna be later in life...

Religion is beautiful , but humanity missunderstand religion if it occurs conflicts about it.

If we understand our own beliefs, others as well and respect it  . There won't be such things as war. Understanding is important...

Some people strives for power and give exuses that it's the religion. It may be the reason for conflicts. But I insist that we are stronger together. we should take care of eachother on the human and animal planet. Yet ... as we know. we only have eachother

Even if its in outer space

Let our religion be science, for science is what we really need in a space age. God did never help us down to earth, nor will he up in space.

Then again taking the freedom of believe is something I do not approve on at all, I think we should all believe what we want.

I even believe in a world that fixes all it's problems will be a religion free world. Whenever things are going well in prosperous countries, religion tends to start deteriorate. So to get back to my point, if we just focus on science in order to help all people, make all people equal in rights and chances, religion will be a thing of the past (in my humble opinion).

Maybe it would be interesting to look at the work done by Jack Fresco in his "Venus Project". He too tries to create equality through a science based society, he speaks of what it will change in peoples behaviour when you give the basic needs to all people make them all equal in that way.

Простите, а для чего вам религия? Если религия нужна вам для того, что бы чувствовать покой, то вовсе не обязательно, что бы местом вашего покоя был какой то специальный храм или помещение. Вы можете и у себя дома хранить верность своей религии и соблюдать требования и обычаи, положенные религией. Любой человек, который уважает чужие взгляды, так же с уважением отнесется к вашей религии. Если же религия вам нужна в качестве показного элемента вроде статусной вещи, которую надо всем и везде показывать, то возникает вопрос: "А действительно ли религия вас интересует?"

На мой взгляд, придумывать и развивать какую-то "специальную религию", это лишнее. Конституция Асгардии говорит о том, что Асгардия объединяет в себе много людей разных национальностей и взглядов и ставит перед собой цель стать Наднациональной страной.

Лучше придумать какую либо красивую и отражающую суть Асгардии скульптуру. И не поклоняться ей, а выражать уважение, как знаку новой точки отсчета в развитии общества нового типа, в котором не будет распрей на религиозном фоне ввиду концепции общего равенства.

If you are starting a new nation/community based on science, technology & hope for a peaceful future then religion shouldn't even be in the discussion. Certainly not one in any way linked to the government.

If you are an adult who believes in a giant invisible super-being that is magically everywhere all at once then you should probably keep that to yourself.

While I like the idea of no hate or friction between religions and people of different culture, I don't like the idea of making one.

I feel that people have religion for various reasons and it helps define who they are as a person. Take that away and you take away individuality. Even those who are atheists are essentially their own religion. No one should say who is right or wrong, because we all have different ways of thinking. As long as you do no harm, why not be an individual? My religion is probably different from everyone else's on here and I certainly wont change from that.

I think a proposal of "No Religion" would be better suited in all honesty. Think of all the wars, problems, arguments, and countless other issues that religions have caused over the centuries for humans. Many have suffered and have lost lives on account of religion and I think this new space nation of ours would be much better off without any of those problems.

sney

i think it´s is better not speak or not teach concepts of hearts gods and speak of only one universal god , one god , one father , without name , whit all names , the all , the one , the first and the end ,the cause and the effect , and say simply * we exist for him and because he is the universe and we are part of him , he love us and we love him *

The problem here is that many religions are explicitly incompatible with others. The solution, i feel, is not to create a universal religion that encompasses all others, but to create a community of peaceful coexistence and respect between people of all faiths and non-faiths. Combine this with a governmental stance of anti religious discrimination and full secularism will create a nation free of the issues that this proposal attempts to handle.

Las religiones solo han causado muerte,  discriminacion, desplazamientos y mucho malestar si se va a empezar algo de semejante magnitud debemos tener en cuenta que si somos personas de diferentes culturas y religiones, eso sera un punto algido para la buena convivencia.

How do you even enforce this?  What's to stop someone from building some sort of shrine in their living room and calling themselves the Grand Poombah of New Religion World?

And why is it a bad thing for different people to believe different things?

There's already religions that combine all the other religions into one.  They haven't ended other religions.

The best thing to do is not to believe things that aren't demonstrably provable or at least demonstrably probable.  However, we can't dictate to other people what they believe.  Remember that one reason the Mongols were able to maintain such a large empire is that they let their conquered subjects believe whatever nonsense they wanted.

This is a very difficult subject, god as an individual. Beyond the foundation that every religion must have, that is, appealing to love, respect and some sort of commandment, etc. People, as we often see, need an object that visualizes it, for example, the Lord with a beard or with 8 hands.

Minimizing what I want to say.

I see my God everyday with my own eyes, give him love, respect and gratitude. I do not have at the same time, no doubt, that he contributed to giving me and other lives. He is our star.

There is no need for the recognition or negations of beliefs and religions from the Asgardian Point of view. It's a secular state, and people are free to believe what they want. Though they should not sell faith for fact.
Peace and freedom doesn't need a religion or faith.

I'm afraid I must disagree with this notion of "no religion". As you may imagine imposing such way of thought on Asgardians, is rather highly authoritarian. And by the values of Asgardia, every human being is regarded as an individual whose way of thinking must be free. Therefore by those standards, they are free to believe or follow any religion they want. Granted, of course, such religion does not impose harm on oneself or another.

Everyone is entitled to follow what religion they so choose, it is part of the Constitution. However, I personally believe that fundamentally Asgadia should promote Spiritualism. The understanding that we're all part of one universe, made of the same materials and each having a conscious experience of being alive within the same universe. That's the unity of one.

That's not a religion, and there is never going to be one religion, religion is a doctrine that you follow, rather than a free spirited quest to understand yourself and the world around you.

What would happen if  I found a new religion to worship the god of money , dubb MOONY  . This religion would be more  universal ,even compared to the religion of Science if somebody else created it.

I support freedom of religion.  This means that I can be a Pagan if I want and you can be a follower of the Aten.  The problem right now on earth is that freedom of religion now means free so long as you support my religion.  Humans are by nature spiritual beings.  I would rather see a rule that says religious hate speak will get you thrown out of Asgardia.

I support freedom of religion.  This means that I can be a Pagan if I want and you can be a follower of the Aten.  The problem right now on earth is that freedom of religion now means free so long as you support my religion.  Humans are by nature spiritual beings.  I would rather see a rule that says religious hate speak will get you thrown out of Asgardia.

I do not support this.

As usual, when religion gets mentioned, it is always the sole reason that Mankind is suffering, it is always religion that causes war, and death, and if we were all just man-fearing atheists instead, The Earth would be a paradise!

What a load of baloney! Ever hear of a creature called Homo-Sapien? It's not God, it's not The Devil. it's not the cross, or the stake, or the symbol, it's not the books or media, it's not even something supernatural. It is US !.

It is OUR greed, OUR narcicism, OUR hatred, OUR insensitivity, and OUR bloody-mindedness, OUR blood-lust, OUR decision to call others 'collateral damage' rather than what it is...Human Murder, carried out by murderous humans. Religion has absolutely, not even 1 iota of a thing to do with the problems of MAN. Mankind is a dishonest, gotta-blame-everyone-and-anything-else-for my-own-evil-and-mistakes type of creature.

Religion is just an EXCUSE for badness (but also a lot of goodness too), politicians and evil people throughout history have used that fact to manipulate millions into carrying out further evil. It's funny how religion is the problem, but no one ever dares to critisize weapon ownership, or the ownership of a very bad set of moralities.

Also I'm pretty sure that Religion has not started 1 single war on Earth, pretty sure it's always been humans that do that, and usually not for God (as many of the ignorant claim) but for greed or hatred, which are HUMAN traits. If a rose by any other name would smell ust as sweet, then it must also be true that give a man any other kind of name, and the evil in this world is still man's, not anyone else's.

What a bad petition, you demonstrate that you desire to replace one bad system, with a differently named, but equally as terrible one, without ever adressing the real issue, which is our continued insistence that a) We are better than anything else and b) Our perpetual ability to ignore the consequences of our own actions.

Such a crazy idea, but, well, you've got my support.

I think it may such a gambling way if we take a look to the purpose of the petition, but why not. A new way of thinking does not always about right or wrong. Sometimes it is only about understanding as wide as our understanding could reach.

Honestly, i like this idea. Beside may create peaceful life, this idea may fulfill human's curiosity on different religion's custom.

My opinion should let the faith as what faith it is, but never let religion inside politics and prohibit it to recruit unless volunteer, make propaganda or any advertise way or teaching of religious that speak bad of other religions, as have been writen in Asgardian Security . As we know most religion have became culture, if we leave faith we will lost our culture. If we combine it, it will become another many endless war of religion. What we need is become open minded person, and tolerant must be subject of practice in every schools.

Pardon me for my English.

Here the speaker is a Buddhist Yogi and also a sympathizer of the Nordic Gods. I support you, Chrayzi. In fact, it is ridiculous to have to change your religion to have respect for another. This little-pointed attitude only shows a great lack of Faith, and it is also a way for the ignorant to feed their "ego", that is, their inner "Devil." It is past time to be like this! I see many of these bad customs here where I live, coming from the evangelicals.

In America there is a philosophy that you separate the church and the state. It is a powerful concept that protects citizens and protects a nation.
I'm going to support the proposed constitution that tackles this. Asgardia is not in the business of governing religions, regardless of what that religion (or lack thereof) is or represents.

As a Nation which is welcoming to everyone, I do not think Asgardia should have a policy of "you should renounce your faith and follow ours if you want to be a member." The Romans used to amalgamate other religions into their own pantheon, and when the Christians arrived?

I agree that too many pointless wars and conflicts have started due to religion, but I've always felt it was more an excuse than a reason.

People believe in what they believe, whether religious or not, and it should never be up to the state to dictate what that belief should be.

With this proposal, it seems that, contrary to what is proposed, EVERYONE who comes to Asgardia with their own beliefs will be discriminated against.

So I am sorry, I cannot support this proposal.

As a Nation which is welcoming to everyone, I do not think Asgardia should have a policy of "you should renounce your faith and follow ours if you want to be a member." The Romans used to amalgamate other religions into their own pantheon, and when the Christians arrived?

I agree that too many pointless wars and conflicts have started due to religion, but I've always felt it was more an excuse than a reason.

People believe in what they believe, whether religious or not, and it should never be up to the state to dictate what that belief should be.

With this proposal, it seems that, contrary to what is proposed, EVERYONE who comes to Asgardia with their own beliefs will be discriminated against.

So I am sorry, I cannot support this proposal.

I will not in good conscience support this.

One of the main ideas behind Asgardia is freedom, are you suggesting we remove that?

I myself am an atheist, but understand that through youthful indoctrination people still choose to believe in the religion of their parents. I have no problem with people that choose to be a follower of any religion, as GENERALLY they themselves are good people. My issue is when religion is bought into governance and education.

Having a religion influence the founding of any system of governance shouldn't be an option at all.

Religion must be an individual choice.  What if someone disagrees with the "one religion" of Asgardia?  I do support respect for all religions.

Combien de guerre, d'injustice de maltraitance et j'en passe au nom de la religion.....Personnellement si certains ont une religion très bien mais qu'ils ne l'imposes a personne. Le respect d'autrui commence par le choix de chacun, ce qui compte ce sont les valeurs de bonté d'âme, l'altruisme, l'empathie et jusqu'à présent nous avons besoin d'aucune religion pour cela mais juste de bon sens....Donc ne réitérons pas nos erreurs passées a chercher le dieu qui vaux mieux que les autres ou je ne sais qu'elles inepties. Croyons juste en nous et notre capacité a  devenir meilleurs.