This is not a dating website. If you are looking for warm bed at night you need to take this topic to a more appropriate website.
Be kinder. Really.
The OP was asking about finding something in common with someone else. This is an attempt at establishing a real relationship, regardless of the physicality or sexual nature of that relationship. All human being seek others with whom they have something in common. It is our basic, tribal nature. The OP simply wishes to find someone else of Asgardia, as they identify most strongly with the Asgardian tribe. Thus, their desire to meet others of the 'tribe'. This is both normal and natural.
Given this is the Off-Topic section, I believe her (presumption as the name is SarahFromFlorida) post was completely and appropriately placed in the correct way, and was worded in such a was as to be as inoffensive as it was reasonable to be.
So, for what it is worth, I do not see where having a single thread dedicated to 'dating within Asgardia' will harm anyone else on these forums. If you aren't fishing for dates, just don't open the link to the thread; simple as that. For my part, I just witnessed a rather too-harsh reply to a simple request and could not help but comment on the fairness of all sides involved.
Taking my own example, I do not expect to be posting in here again myself as I am pretty sure my wife would become most upset with me. :)