Duskclaw your not really wrong but I think basic hand to hand is needed for defending and taking on threats. In the U.S. navy are there not navy troops trained to board enemy ships in case? They have to have training, you can't hand a person a gun and equipment and expect them to know how to use it. Other than that, your point isn't bad, it's very good really.

Solkiro I wish I could shake your hand, you definelty understand we should be prepared and not expect to be left alone and no issues, you have to be a dumbass and no prepare for a fight at least, thank you for actually thinking unlike half of these idiots.

Hello Boonejohn97, Nice to meet you here, may I respectfully ask that you not refer to others as "idiots". May I mention also I have found that respecting others perspectives in debate is often the best way to come to a consensus. thank you so much.

Sorry, it just makes me mad how blind people are, I'd love for peace but for this generation it may not happen Till we all die and They expect it to go perfect. I am sorry, just hard to hold back.

I will do my best to refrain.

No problem @Boonejohn97 Thank you for your understanding on the matter.

You don't "expect it to go perfect" - that's just idiocy and deserves such a label - you engineer it to happen.

Not a problem, I'm just very open to asgardia and don't wanna risk all the work for nothing, you know like getting it set up and almost ready then it get hit by a missile or something come crashing into orbit. I know a bit much but not everyone is peaceful, Or at least not for long. I'm sorry just space is one of my major passions, I'm trying to join the navy and Study, subjects needed to work and be space. So understand I wouldn't want to do all that then it goes down the drain because people didn't want to willing to defend or fight. So if i go to far just say something. And i do get their points

People will always find a way to ruin it. 9/11 is a perfect example of that. We thought nothing could happen to our land then it happened.

I think we can learn from history to answer this question. Not everyone is willing to fight. In cases where countries require all citizens to spend a number of years in the military, this is not always welcome. We must also consider the placement of Asgardia. How will the other nations view this?

With so many nations on Earth, the more advanced nations will certainly take note of Asgardia "crossing" their borders. We already see nations taking issue with simple satellites crossing borders or peeking in, for fear of potential espionage. Satellites have been lost this way. Now imagine their fear of a space station full of soldiers floating over their heads. This may also be a breach of the weaponization of space, as a military has weapons. With a full military in orbit, it would be simple enough to deploy into any location on Earth within hours via shuttles or drop pods. Earth-based nations know this, and would surely create countermeasures or plans for this. This turns Asgardia into a target then, with weapons poised on the station. In the station is hit, and entire nation could be wiped out.

Thus, I think it better if Asgardia remains neutral as is the current plan. Since citizens are permitted to have duel citizenship, if anything, the various nations of the world would be providing military training FOR Asgardia. This creates a broad mix of military and civilian talent with no cost to Asgardia.

I've stated in another thread the benefits of martial arts, and I think that it is the best way to go. Not everyone wants to fight, or is willing to learn, so they don't need to. But those who seek to defend themselves may take up martial arts. And as stated earlier in the thread, martial artists are respected, so having a space nation where much of the population knows martial arts should only increase the nation's standing in the public eye. It also generates a sense of pride for the citizenry. (Not to mention interesting martial arts tournaments between Earth and Asgardia, or just on Asgardia!)

Hello Sean,

The martial arts idea is a good one but, it does not work well for folks who aren't able to walk and such. Citizens with disabilities would need an alternative way to protect themselves. Which makes it difficult to have all citizens receive ma training

Very true, Brandon. Martial arts isn't for everyone, and those with physical or mental disabilities may find it difficult to even perform. I don't know what would be a good alternative for people in that category, or if they even should.

Honestly, I don't think we have anything to fear of being struck by a missile early on. During such a stage, most of the Asgardian population wouldn't be on the station, and the political backlash towards any nation for the unprovoked attack would be astronomical, not just by the Asgardian population. Attacking a non-hostile entity would only lead to the aggressor being shamed on the world stage, and harm them economically. As long as Asgardia is not the aggressor, it should be safe. Even if only the aggressor declares war, public opinion across the world would likely turn against them as long as Asgardia doesn't return a declaration of war.

I think basic hand to hand maybe like boxing maybe or something better would be good, martial arts isn't for everyone. But that should be 1 of 3 of the mandatories

I feel like the military and security issues are being treated like some kind of game lately. 

That really disappoints me.

Regular citizens should be free to choose "if" and "what" to learn, the most important thing is to be sure that those lessons are accessible to everyone.Asgardia is not about being proud of being its citizens, it's the exact opposite, it's about being proud of being just earthlings, it's not Asgardia vs the world, it's about Asgardia helping it.

We don't need an army, we don't need weapons like in cartoons and nobody is going to hit us with a missile anytime soon. What we need is credibility, our main goal is to influence politics with common sense, not with this useless stuff, I'd really like to see more of my fellows Asgardians taking these things more seriously.

Sorry for that, but it needed to be said, and it's my honest opinion.

Politics have no place in asgardia, it's a declaration. And that's why I stopped my conceal weapons article, we need to focus on how we are going to live homes, food, accessible resources, products, fashion (I could care less really), and routines